Navigating the Numbers

Insights from our Learning Center

S-Corporation Paying Employee Bonuses: How Much Does That Bonus Really Cost Your Business?

S-Corporation Paying Employee Bonuses: How Much Does That Bonus Really Cost Your Business?

Hint: Your $5,000 Employee Bonus May Actually Cost About $4,127

Employee bonuses are a powerful tool for motivating your team, increasing retention, and rewarding exceptional work. But as a small business owner—especially if you’re running an S-Corporation—you need to know that the cost of a bonus isn’t limited to the amount you hand over to your employee. In fact, a $5,000 bonus may only look like $4,127 when the dust settles. Let’s break down the true expenses, step by step.

1. Starting at the Surface: The Gross Bonus Amount

The face value of the bonus itself—$5,000—is straightforward. This is the number most employers focus on, but it’s just the tip of the iceberg. Beneath that $5,000 figure lie several hidden costs that can significantly increase the final price tag.

2. The Hidden Costs: Employer Payroll Taxes

Employer Payroll Taxes can be surprising. When you pay an employee their bonus, you’re also responsible for employer-side taxes, including:

  • Social Security Tax (6.2%): For a $5,000 bonus, that’s an extra $310.
  • Medicare Tax (1.45%): Adds another $72.50 to your cost.
  • State Unemployment Tax (SUTA): Rates vary, and many employers have hit the max by year-end. But assuming a 2% rate, that’s $100 more.
  • Federal Unemployment Tax (FUTA): At 0.6%, this is an additional $30 if you haven’t already maxed for the year.

Total Employer Payroll Taxes: $512.50

3. Workers’ Compensation Insurance

Your workers’ compensation insurance premiums often factor in wages including bonuses. If your rate is about 1%, this adds another $50 to the cost.

4. Additional Benefits Costs

If you offer employee benefits like a SIMPLE IRA or 401(k) match, a bonus increases your matching contributions. Assuming 3% match, you’re looking at an extra $150 on that $5,000 bonus.

5. Administrative Fees

From payroll processing to bookkeeping adjustments, bonuses can lead to extra administrative fees. Let’s estimate around $100 for this—especially if you outsource payroll services or rely on third-party providers.

6. Total Cost Before Tax Savings

Let’s tally up the costs:

  • Gross Bonus: $5,000.00
  • Employer Payroll Taxes: $512.50
  • Workers’ Comp: $50.00
  • Benefits (Retirement Match): $150.00
  • Admin Fees: $100.00

Total Cost: $5,812.50

7. The Silver Lining: Tax Deductions for Businesses

Here’s some good news: Bonuses are deductible business expenses. Let’s assume a combined Federal and State tax rate of about 29% (22% federal + 7% state). On the $5,812.50 total, you’ll save roughly $1,685.63 in taxes.

8. The Net Cost to Your Business

After factoring in tax savings, here’s the real cost:

$5,812.50 (Total Cost) – $1,685.63 (Tax Savings) = $4,126.87

In other words, that “$5,000 bonus” you were planning to give could only cost you about $4,127 once all is said and done.

Have Questions?

Did we miss any cost factors or have you discovered other hidden expenses in your own business? Drop a comment below and join the conversation!


Conclusion: Knowledge is Power in Business Finance

Key Takeaways:

  • Bonuses aren’t just face-value numbers. Employer payroll taxes, workers’ comp, benefits, and admin fees add up quickly.
  • Tax deductions help. Though you’ll pay more upfront, your tax write-offs cushion the blow.
  • Plan ahead. Understanding all these components allows you to budget correctly while still rewarding your team and improving employee retention.

Ready to get even smarter about your small business finances?

Until next time, keep building your business the smart way!

Disclaimer: The tax information provided here is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as or relied upon for tax or legal advice. This information is based on the laws and regulations in effect at the time of issuance, and we do not undertake any obligation to update this information after the date of its release. Please speak with your tax professional or attorney for guidance specific to your circumstances.

View Disclaimer

Archives

Recent Posts

© Copyright 2022 - 2024 Aaron Stegner CPA. All rights reserved.
Website by Mixtureweb
Please Fill Our Our Web Form.
Our Goal is to Discover How We Can Partner Together
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
We are currently focusing our expertise on supporting self-employed individuals and business owners. If you are a self-employed professional or run your own business, we're here to partner with you for all your accounting needs.
Name
President, VP, Member, Owner...
What services are inquiring about? (Check all that apply)
How did you hear about us?
Aaron Stegner CPA, Ltd. is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy. In order to provide you the services requested, we need to store and process your personal data. If you consent to us storing your personal data for this purpose, please check the box below.
From time to time, we would like to contact you about our products and services, as well as other content that may be of interest to you. If you consent to us contacting you for this purpose, please check the box below.
If you would you like to opt-in to SMS messaging please check the box below. We do not text marketing or automated messaging. It will be used for conversational purposes only. We do not share or sell any data including SMS information.